Hybrid Versus Open Pollinated Sweet Corn

If you have been perusing the website or catalog, you may have noticed that we carry both open pollinated and hybrid sweet corn. The hybrid sweet corn is actually the only hybrid that we carry. So why do we carry both? What are the differences and how do you choose the right one for your garden? In today’s blog, we’ll discuss the fundamental differences and pros and cons of hybrid and open pollinated corn.

What is Open Pollinated Sweet Corn?

The basic fundamental between hybrid and open-pollinated is how they’re bred. Open pollinated means that the plant is fertilized naturally, like by wind, insects, or birds.

Seed growers save seed from open-pollinated varieties over generations to create varieties that are relatively stable, but still genetically diverse. If you save seed from open pollinated corn, you will get the same corn next season, so long as you don’t have another variety nearby that cross-pollinated it. 

To isolate different varieties, growers usually use distance or time. Crops that flower at different times won’t cross-pollinate.

Heirlooms are open-pollinated varieties dating to before 1940.

Corn is wind pollinated. Home gardeners should separate varieties by 600 ft. for home use, or 1/2 to 1 mile for absolute purity. Save at least 500 seeds from at least 10% of the plants to maintain vigor and genetic diversity of the variety.

Bodacious RM - sugary enhanced hybrid Sweet Corn
Bodacious RM – sugary enhanced hybrid Sweet Corn

What is Hybrid Sweet Corn?

Hybrid crops are the first generation crosses of two varieties. In breeding hybrid sweet corn, seed growers select two genetically pure lines of corn to cross.

Breeding hybrid corn is tricky! Typically, growers will alternate rows of the two types of corn. Though corn has both male and female parts, growers think about them as male and female parents. 

Growers leave the male parent stalks intact. These will provide the pollen for the pollination. Growers remove the tassels from the female parent rows as they form, ensuring that they don’t produce pollen. The pollen from the male parent rows will fertilize the silks of the female parent rows. The growers then harvest the seeds from the female parent rows.

This technique ensures growers get the desired mix of genetics. 

During the season, growers also go through and remove and volunteer or “off-type” corn in a technique called rogueing.

Stowell’s Evergreen Sweet Corn
Stowell’s Evergreen Sweet Corn

Pros and Cons Open Pollinated Sweet Corn

While we love open pollinated crops, we know they come with a unique set of benefits and challenges. 

The Pros

  • Farmers and gardeners can easily save seed from open-pollinated sweet corn.
  • Foodies often find that open-pollinated varieties have more “real corn flavor” rather than just sweetness.
  • Growers can save open-pollinated varieties can over years to adapt to a specific local climate.
  • Home gardeners may enjoy that they tend to have an extended harvest period. 
  • Open-pollinated varieties typically have higher protein content than hybrid varieties. 
  • When pigs, chickens, horses, and cows have a choice between open-pollinated and hybrid corn, the animals invariably prefer the old open-pollinated varieties (possibly because of the protein content).

The Cons

  • They typically aren’t as sugary sweet as hybrid sweet corn varieties.
  • They don’t store well and are best used or preserved quickly after harvest.
  • Open pollinated corn isn’t uniform in size, which can be an issue for commercial growers.
  • It also doesn’t mature all at the same time, another feature which can be a struggle for commercial growers.

Pros and Cons of Hybrid Sweet Corn

While hybrid may be a typical choice for market growers, it too has its pros and cons.

The Pros

  • Hybrid corn tends to mature all at once, which is ideal for market growers. 
  • The ears are uniform in size.
  • They are sugary sweet and hold their sweetness well in storage. 
  • Hybrids often have better disease resistance. 

The uniformity of hybrid sweet size and maturity are the two main reasons we offer hybrid for our commercial growers.

The Cons

  • Hybrid seeds tend to rot in cool soil. 
  • They may have weak seedling vigor. 
  • The ears are more susceptible to insect damage than open pollinated corn. 
  • You cannot reliably save seed from hybrid corn.

Corn Seedlings in a FieldWhich Should You Grow?

What you should grow depends on your needs and personal preferences. As mentioned above, hybrid sweet corn’s uniformity is a key feature for many of our market gardeners, but if you’re looking to enjoy sweet corn over an extended period, open pollinated may be the right choice.

Open pollinated is also a good choice if you’re hoping to save seed. Saving seed from your corn can help preserve genetic diversity, connect you with your land, and adapt a variety to your garden’s specific conditions as you work to save seed from the best plants over the years. 

If open-pollinated corn is new to you, we suggest planting less than 1/4 lb. until you are familiar with its characteristics. It grows a bit differently and has a distinct flavor. Don’t forget, you’ll need to use it more quickly, too. Open pollinated corn doesn’t store quite as well as hybrid corn. 

For good pollination and ear development, plant open-pollinated corn in blocks at least 5-6 rows wide, and hybrid corn in blocks at least 4 rows wide.

Want to save seed from your open pollinated sweet corn? Check out the 8 Steps to Saving Corn Seed.

Sowing Seeds: Cold Stratification

Each winter gardeners dream of spring, tucking seeds into the soil indoors where they’re safe from winter’s chill. Most of garden seeds like tomatoes, zinnias, cabbage, and basil all benefit from relatively warm soil conditions. But, there are some seeds that actually require cold temperatures to germinate. This is when gardeners must use a method called cold stratification.

What is Cold Stratification?

Cold stratification is a seed starting technique where the gardener exposes the seeds to cold, moist conditions to mimic natural conditions. For some species, these conditions are necessary for the seed to break dormancy. 

Seeds that require cold stratification typically have a hard seed coating. In a natural setting, the frosts, snow, low temperatures, and rain of winter break down the coating.

Yellow Swallowtail Butterfly on Purple Coneflower (Echinacea purpurea)What Seeds Require Cold Stratification

While you can simply plunk many annual vegetable, flower, and herb seeds straight into warm soil in the spring, some varieties, especially native perennials, need or benefit from cold stratification.

Some species like Butterfly Weed will germinate without cold stratification. However, they may have a lower germination rate and germinate more slowly. Others, like the Yellow Coneflower, require cold stratification. I have marked those species that require cold stratification to break dormancy with a “*.”

This list includes many of the common plants that benefit from cold stratification but isn’t comprehensive. Always check on your specific variety’s needs. 

How to Cold Stratify Seeds

There are several techniques for cold stratifying seeds, but we like to keep it as simple as possible at SESE. However, these seeds will still need to be started far in advance of your typical crops. While a few species will germinate after just 3 weeks of cold stratification, most need 2 to 4 months before they break dormancy.

To stratify seeds indoors, sow them as directed in pots or flats, and then place them in the refrigerator for 2 to 4 months. Keep the soil moist during this period. If you have access to a cold frame or hoop house, you can also set your pots or flats into it for the winter.

Some native perennials may still have relatively low germination rates, even after cold stratification. 

That’s what makes them sow tricky to grow. Thankfully, once established, they will often self sow or you can divide them after a couple of years. 

Cold Stratification Alternative: Direct Sow Fall Planting

If cold stratification doesn’t sound like a fun project for you, there is an easy alternative, direct sowing in fall. As long as you live in a region where the winters naturally provide moist, cold conditions, the stratification process will happen over the winter.

In a previous post, Spring Flowers: Fall Sowing, we discuss how to use this technique and what flowers grow well using this method. Some flowers, like Dara, will grow well when fall sown even if they don’t require cold stratification.

Generally, we recommend fall sowing any of your seeds about 4 to 6 weeks before your first expected frost date. 

Crop Rotation by Plant Family

Crop rotation is an essential tool in the organic gardener’s tool box. It’s an excellent way to reduce pest and disease pressure without resorting to pesticides, fungicides, or other chemical amendments. There are many methods of crop rotation but we prefer to rotate crops on a 2 to 4-year plan by plant family. This is a simple method for small gardeners and market growers alike, whether you’re working with flowers, herbs, or vegetables.

What is Crop Rotation?

Crop rotation is a system of gardening organization and planting that ensures you don’t grow specific types of plants in the same bed for multiple years in a row. Some farmers like to rotate by nutritional needs (ex. Heavy feeders, light feeders, and givers), but we prefer to rotate by family (related groups of plants).

For a large commercial garden or home vegetable garden, we encourage growers to rotate on a four-year plan, meaning that you don’t grow a type of crop in the same bed for four years.

If this isn’t feasible, do what you’re able. A two or three-year rotation is better than none!

Keeping track of your rotation each year is essential. Keep a garden journal (graph paper is helpful for sketching beds) or a garden planner app.

Benefits of Crop Rotation

Why can’t you just keep planting crops in the same spot? When we plant the same crop in a bed year after year, it uses the same nutrients and encourages disease and pests to build up in the soil.

Crop rotation can eliminate these issues and make your garden healthier. It may:

  • Reduce the risk of pests and diseases.
  • Improve soil health and fertility.
  • Reduce the need for chemical amendments.
  • Increase yields.
  • Improve soil carbon sequestration.

There’s even some new evidence that crop rotation may help reduce risks of crop loss in a changing climate.

What are the Different Plant Families?

Most of the common vegetable crops and even some flowers and herbs fall into a few larger plant families. Prevalent pest and disease issues often affect specific families. 

For example, some cucurbits like pumpkins, winter squash, and summer squash are all affected by vine borers, blight is a common fungal disease in the nightshades like tomatoes and potatoes, and many of the brassicas like broccoli, cauliflower, and cabbage are prone to cabbage worm issues.

Rotation often helps prevent theses issues. For example, garlic rust is most prevalent in garlic, but it can also infect onions and leeks when they’re planted closely or in an infected bed. 

Here are the basic crop families:

The Nightshades (Solanaceae spp.)

  • Tomatoes
  • Tomatillos
  • Ground Cherries
  • Peppers
  • Eggplants
  • Potatoes
  • Tobacco
  • Garden Huckleberry
  • Petunias

The Pea Family (Fabaceae spp.)

  • Pole beans
  • Bush beans
  • Asparagus beans
  • Fava beans
  • Soybeans (edamame)
  • Peas
  • Sweet Peas
  • Cowpeas

The Beet Family (Chenopodiaceae spp. or Amaranthaceae spp.)

  • Beets
  • Quinoa
  • Swiss Chard
  • Spinach 
  • Amaranth

The Cucurbits (Curcurbitaceae spp.)

  • Cucumbers
  • Zucchini 
  • Summer Squash
  • Winter Squash
  • Pumpkins
  • Gourds
  • Watermelon
  • Melons

The Brassicas (Brassicaceae spp.)

  • Cabbage
  • Collards
  • Brussels sprouts
  • Kale
  • Broccoli
  • Cauliflower
  • Radishes
  • Kohlrabi
  • Mustards
  • Asian greens (bok choy)
  • Turnips
  • Arugula

The Carrot Family (Apiaceae spp.)

  • Carrots
  • Dara
  • Celery
  • Fennel
  • Cilantro
  • Parsley
  • Parsnips
  • Dill

The Alliums (Alliacaeae)

  • Bulb Onions
  • Garlic
  • Leeks
  • Perennial Onions
  • Shallots
  • Chives

The Daisy Family (Asteraceae spp.)

  • Sunflowers
  • Lettuce
  • Endive
  • Radicchio
  • Asters

How to Crops Rotate by Family

There isn’t a one-size fits all formula for every garden. Just keep moving crops. For example, if you grow tomatoes (a nightshade) in a bed one year, you could grow broccoli (a brassica) the following year, then bulb onions (alliums), and then finally bush beans (pea family), before growing another nightshade, like peppers.

Buckwheat (cover crops)Other Considerations

Rotating by family is the basic way to get the job done, but there are some other techniques you may also want to include.

Fertility Requirements

As you plan your rotation, you may want to consider the fertility requirements of different plant families. Many growers choose to rotate crops through a bed, starting with high fertility needs to low fertility needs. Often, they will rest the bed for a year or put it in a cover crop in between cycles. 

Heavy feeders are vegetables that need a good bit of nitrogen to thrive, like tomatoes, sweet corn, and broccoli. Light feeders like garlic, parsnips, and Swiss chard need less nitrogen to thrive. Givers or fixers are the last category. These are the nitrogen-fixing members of the pea family. They rarely need much supplemental nitrogen as they can convert atmospheric nitrogen into its usable form.

You can also take this a step further with cover crops.

Adding Cover Crops to Your Rotation

Adding cover crops to your rotation can also make a tremendous difference in the health of your soil and productivity of your garden. In large gardens, you may decide to leave beds or sections in a cover crop for an entire year to rest the soil.

In smaller gardens, this may not be possible. Don’t fret, you can use the off-seasons and “in-between times” for cover crops. 

Winter cover crops are a great way to improve soil health during the slow season. You can also plant a cover crop as soon as a crop is finished. For example, if you grow a bed of early cabbages, you can sow the bed in a cover crop like buckwheat during the summer. In late summer or fall, cut the buckwheat and use the bed for a fall crop.

 

Crop rotation is a simple way to improve the health of your soil and garden. As your planning next season’s garden, think about incorporating crop rotation by family for a more productive year. 

Saving the Past for the Future